Lawyer Portal Careers Contact Us

Law Society of Alberta

  • Who We Are
    • Indigenous Land Acknowledgements

      Indigenous land acknowledgements to recognize the traditional territories that the Law Society of Alberta serves.
      • About Us
      • Executive Leadership Team
      • Board & Committees
        • Board Directory
        • Board Meetings
        • Committees and Task Forces
        • Other Bodies
      • Key Initiatives
        • Indigenous Initiatives
        • COVID-19 Updates
      • Engagement with Public and Profession
      • Affiliations
      • Annual & Financial Reports
      • Strategic Plan
      • Awards & Scholarships
        • Distinguished Service Awards
        • Recognition of Service
        • Scholarships
      • Frequently Asked Questions
  • For the Public
    • Complaints

      Find out more about the types of complaints the Law Society can or cannot help you with and how to file a complaint.
      • Find a Lawyer
      • Complaints
      • Finding Files & Wills
      • Public Resources
      • Financial Claims
      • Notices
      • Careers
  • Lawyers & Students
    • COVID-19 Updates

      An archive of announcements, information and resources.
      • Become a Lawyer
      • Membership Services
      • Forms & Certificates
      • Making A Payment
      • Trust Accounting & Safety
        • Responsible Lawyers
        • Filing Requirements
        • Anti-Money Laundering Model Rules
      • Professional Development
      • Fraud & Loss Prevention
      • Practice Advisors
      • Practice Management Consultations
      • Approved Legal Services Providers
      • Complaints
      • Equity Ombudsperson
      • Alberta Lawyers Indemnity Association
        • Report a Claim
        • Group Policy
        • ALIAlerts
        • ALIAdvisories
  • Resource Centre
    • Newest resource:

      Understanding and Avoiding Law Society Complaints
      • Learning Centre
      • Student Resources
      • Public Resources
      • Disaster Planning and Recovery
      • Upcoming Events
      • Media Room
      • eBulletins
      • Latest News
      • Lawyer Programs
        • Mentor Connect
        • Mentor Express
        • AdvisorLink
        • Locum Connect
        • Practice Management Consultations
        • SoloNet
        • Assist
      • Key Resources
        • Client Relationships
        • Communication & Research
        • Equity & Diversity
        • Ethics & Professionalism
        • Practice Management
        • Substantive Legal Knowledge
        • Trust Accounting & Safety
        • Wellness
        • Webinars
  • Regulation
    • Act, Code & Rules

      The Law Society of Alberta derives its authority from the Legal Profession Act and sets out standards through its Rules and Code of Conduct.
      • Act, Code & Rules
      • Hearings
        • Schedule
        • Decisions & Outcomes
        • Complaint Dismissal Appeals
        • Adjudicator Directory
        • Tribunal Office
      • Notices
        • Custodianship
        • Disbarment
        • Reinstatement
        • Resignation
        • Suspension
      • Unauthorized Practice of Law
  • Find a Lawyer
Resource Centre
  • Learning Centre
  • Lawyer Programs
    • Mentor Connect
      • Mentor Moments
    • Mentor Express
    • AdvisorLink
      • AdvisorLink Online Request
    • Locum Connect
      • Locum Listing
      • Locum Opportunity Listing
    • SoloNet
  • Key Resources
    • Client Relationship Management
    • Communication, Analytical & Research Skills
    • Ethics & Professionalism
    • Equity & Diversity
    • Practice Management
      • Leaving the Practice of Law
      • Returning to Practice
    • Substantive Legal Knowledge
    • Trust Accounting & Safety
    • Wellness
    • Webinars
      • Approved Legal Services Provider Webinar
      • Respectful Workplace Model Policy Webinar
  • Disaster Planning and Recovery
  • Student Resources
  • Public Resources
  • Upcoming Events
  • Media Room
  • eBulletins
  • Latest from the Law Society
  • Home
  • Resource Centre
  • Key Resources
  • Client Relationship Management
  • Untying the Knot: Withdrawing from a Client
Untying the Knot: Withdrawing from a Client

Lawyers frequently ask the Practice Advisors whether circumstances justify firing a client. Even if the answer is yes, sometimes the lawyer is obligated to continue acting.

When withdrawing, a lawyer must avoid causing prejudice to the client and to others, including witnesses, the court, jurors and opposing counsel and parties. A lawyer may be obliged to continue regardless of a breakdown in the lawyer client-relationship.

Unlawful or unethical instructions entitle the lawyer to withdraw, but the cost to the client or the administration of justice may be high.[1] For example, a client intent on committing perjury poses an ethical dilemma. If a lawyer fires the client in the midst of trial he or she risks painting the client as a liar. Soldiering on, however, would be a breach of the lawyer’s duty of candour to the court.

The reasons for withdrawing may be less dramatic in most cases: non-payment of fees, conflicts of interest, non-cooperation or other actions may undermine the relationship between lawyer and client. While these situations justify withdrawal, in certain cases lawyers may not withdraw if it will cause undue prejudice to the client.

Prejudice is more than mere inconvenience. The Supreme Court stated in R. v. Cunningham[2] that, when counsel seeks to withdraw for non-payment of fees, the court may refuse the request if the withdrawal would harm the administration of justice. It is essential that lawyers request leave to withdraw at the earliest possible time, and that the client has reasonable notice to obtain other counsel. The court may refuse to grant a request to withdraw only in “exceptional circumstances”, and the discretion should be used “exceedingly sparingly”.

Delay is the most frequent concern. For instance, a trial may be imminent, a deal closing or a limitation looming.[3] If a hearing can be adjourned or a closing postponed, and no one is adversely affected, then a lawyer may withdraw. In contrast, in R. v. Montgomery[4], the court refused a pre-trial application to withdraw where the accused had been in remand for over two years.

Other relevant factors include availability of replacement counsel, deteriorating evidence, the feasibility of the client’s self-representation or the complexity of the case.[5] The Ontario case of Nicolardi v Daley[6] discussed the client’s ability to find a new lawyer. Trial was over five months away, but if the client had taken his lawyer’s advice to find alternate counsel, he would have been able to retain a new lawyer seven months before trial. There was no peril resulting from a change of counsel, nor did the accused represent that he would be unable to pay a new lawyer to take over this file.

In the face of a conflict of interest, a lawyer will be required to withdraw from a representation. However, a desire to accept a new, potentially lucrative, client does not provide good cause to withdraw from legal services of the current client.[7] It is not appropriate for a law firm to “’dump’ one client in order to take on another ‘conflicted’ prospective client whose file looks more attractive.”[8]

Briefly, a duty of loyalty binds a lawyer to zealous commitment to the client’s cause. There may be many circumstances which entitle a lawyer to unfettered termination of the retainer. But, in “exceptional circumstances”, the lawyer must see the matter through if the client will be unduly prejudiced by the withdrawal.

Written by: Ross McLeod, Practice Advisor


 

[1] See R. v. White 2010 ABCA 66.

[2] 2010 SCC 10

[3] Re A.L. 2003 ABQB 905

[4] 2013 BCSC 1007

[5] Kovinich v. Kovinich [2008] O.J. No. 5917

[6] [2003] O.J. No. 1303

[7] CNR v. McKercher 2013 SCC 39

[8] Toddglen Construction Ltd. V Concord Adex Developments Corp., [2004] OJ No. 1788

Printed from https://www.lawsociety.ab.ca on January 17, 2021 at 6:38:25 PM
Law Society of Alberta ©2021 Law Society of Alberta.
  • Latest
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Careers
©2021 Law Society of Alberta.
  • Who We Are
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Executive Leadership Team
    • Board & Committees
      • Back
      • Board Directory
      • Board Meetings
      • Committees and Task Forces
      • Other Bodies
    • Key Initiatives
      • Back
      • Indigenous Initiatives
      • COVID-19 Updates
    • Engagement with Public and Profession
    • Affiliations
    • Annual & Financial Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • Awards & Scholarships
      • Back
      • Distinguished Service Awards
      • Recognition of Service
      • Scholarships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • For the Public
    • Back
    • Find a Lawyer
    • Complaints
    • Finding Files & Wills
    • Public Resources
    • Financial Claims
    • Notices
    • Careers
  • Lawyers & Students
    • Back
    • Become a Lawyer
    • Membership Services
    • Forms & Certificates
    • Making A Payment
    • Trust Accounting & Safety
      • Back
      • Responsible Lawyers
      • Filing Requirements
      • Anti-Money Laundering Model Rules
    • Professional Development
    • Fraud & Loss Prevention
    • Practice Advisors
    • Practice Management Consultations
    • Approved Legal Services Providers
    • Complaints
    • Equity Ombudsperson
    • Alberta Lawyers Indemnity Association
      • Back
      • Report a Claim
      • Group Policy
      • ALIAlerts
      • ALIAdvisories
  • Resource Centre
    • Back
    • Learning Centre
    • Student Resources
    • Public Resources
    • Disaster Planning and Recovery
    • Upcoming Events
    • Media Room
    • eBulletins
    • Latest News
    • Lawyer Programs
      • Back
      • Mentor Connect
      • Mentor Express
      • AdvisorLink
      • Locum Connect
      • Practice Management Consultations
      • SoloNet
      • Assist
    • Key Resources
      • Back
      • Client Relationships
      • Communication & Research
      • Equity & Diversity
      • Ethics & Professionalism
      • Practice Management
      • Substantive Legal Knowledge
      • Trust Accounting & Safety
      • Wellness
      • Webinars
  • Regulation
    • Back
    • Act, Code & Rules
    • Hearings
      • Back
      • Schedule
      • Decisions & Outcomes
      • Complaint Dismissal Appeals
      • Adjudicator Directory
      • Tribunal Office
    • Notices
      • Back
      • Custodianship
      • Disbarment
      • Reinstatement
      • Resignation
      • Suspension
    • Unauthorized Practice of Law
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Lawyer Portal
  • Contact

Email: AdvisorLink

Fill in the form below to get in touch with AdvisorLink
  • 1. AdvisorLink (operated by the Office of the Practice Advisors) and the Advisors accept no liability whatsoever arising from assistance given to lawyers or to any persons claiming through or under them.
    2. Lawyers are obligated to independently verify statements of law, procedure or fact made to them by the Advisor, before relying on them.
    3. AdvisorLink must not be used as a substitute for the lawyers’ own thorough research and analysis or for the lawyers’ own professional judgment.

Email: Accounting

Fill in the form below to get in touch with Accounting
  • Drop files here or
      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

    Email: Customer Service

    Fill in the form below to get in touch.
    • Drop files here or
        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

      Email: General Feedback

      Fill in the form below to get in touch with General Feedback
      • Drop files here or
          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

        Email: Communications and Media Relations

        Fill in the form below to get in touch with Communications and Media Relations.
        • Drop files here or
            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

          Email: Indigenous Initiatives Liaison

          Fill in the form below to get in touch with Andrea Menard
          • Drop files here or
              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

            Email: Membership Services

            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Membership Services
            • Drop files here or
                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

              Email: Manager, Membership Services

              Fill in the form below to get in touch with Tina McKay
              • Drop files here or
                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                Email: Elizabeth Aspinall

                Fill in the form below to get in touch with Elizabeth Aspinall
                • Drop files here or
                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                  Email: Jesse Mackenzie

                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with Jesse Mackenzie
                  • Drop files here or
                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                    Email: Allan Guty

                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Allan Guty
                    • Drop files here or
                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                      Email: SoloNet

                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with SoloNet
                      • Drop files here or
                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                        Email: Practice Management

                        • Drop files here or
                            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                          Email: Nancy Bains

                          Fill in the form below to get in touch with Nancy Bains
                          • Drop files here or
                              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                            Email: Inform Trust Safety

                            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Inform Trust Safety
                            • Drop files here or
                                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                              Email: Trust Safety

                              Fill in the form below to get in touch with Trust Safety
                              • Drop files here or
                                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                Email: Information Management

                                Fill in the form below to get in touch with Information Management
                                • Drop files here or
                                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                  Email: Election

                                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with Election
                                  • Drop files here or
                                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                    Email: Justicia Project

                                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Justicia Project
                                    • Drop files here or
                                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                      Email: Locum Connect

                                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with Locum Connect
                                      • Drop files here or
                                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                        Email: Mentor Connect

                                        Fill in the form below to get in touch with Mentor Connect
                                        • Drop files here or
                                            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                          Email: Mentor Express

                                          Fill in the form below to get in touch with Mentor Express
                                          • Drop files here or
                                              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                            Email: Indigenous Law Student Summer Employment Program

                                            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Indigenous Law Student Summer Employment Program
                                            • Drop files here or
                                                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                              Email: ALIA

                                              Fill in the form below to get in touch with ALIA
                                              • Drop files here or
                                                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                Email: ALIAlert fraud alerts

                                                Fill in the form below to get in touch with ALIAlert fraud alerts
                                                • Drop files here or
                                                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                  Email: Equity Ombudsperson

                                                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with Elizabeth Aspinall
                                                  • Drop files here or
                                                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                    Email: Tribunal Office

                                                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Tribunal Office
                                                    • Drop files here or
                                                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                      Email: Custodianship

                                                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with Custodianship
                                                      • Drop files here or
                                                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.