Lawyer Portal Careers Contact Us

Law Society of Alberta

  • Who We Are
    • Indigenous Land Acknowledgements

      Indigenous land acknowledgements to recognize the traditional territories that the Law Society of Alberta serves.
      • About Us
      • Executive Leadership Team
      • Board & Committees
        • Board Directory
        • Board Meetings
        • Committees
        • Other Bodies
      • Key Initiatives
        • Indigenous Initiatives
        • COVID-19 Updates
      • Engagement with Public and Profession
      • Affiliations
      • Annual & Financial Reports
      • Strategic Plan
      • Awards & Scholarships
        • Distinguished Service Awards
        • Recognition of Service
        • Scholarships
      • Frequently Asked Questions
  • For the Public
    • Complaints

      Find out more about the types of complaints the Law Society can or cannot help you with and how to file a complaint.
      • Find a Lawyer
      • Complaints
      • Finding Files & Wills
      • Public Resources
      • Financial Claims
      • Notices
      • Careers
  • Lawyers & Students
    • Become a Lawyer in Alberta

      Find information on how to apply to be a lawyer in Alberta whether you are internationally trained, a law student or a lawyer from another Canadian jurisdiction.
      • Become a Lawyer
      • Membership Services
      • Forms & Certificates
      • Making A Payment
      • Trust Accounting & Safety
        • Responsible Lawyers
        • Filing Requirements
        • Anti-Money Laundering Model Rules
      • Professional Development
      • Fraud & Loss Prevention
      • Practice Advisors
      • Practice Management Consultations
      • Approved Legal Services Providers
      • Complaints
      • Equity Ombudsperson
      • Alberta Lawyers Indemnity Association
        • Report a Claim
        • Group Policy
        • ALIAlerts
        • ALIAdvisories
  • Resource Centre
    • Newest resource:

      Working Remotely — Applying the National Mobility Rules
      • Learning Centre
      • Student Resources
      • Public Resources
      • Disaster Planning and Recovery
      • Upcoming Events
      • Media Room
      • eBulletins
      • Latest News
      • Lawyer Programs
        • Mentor Connect
        • Mentor Express
        • AdvisorLink
        • Locum Connect
        • Practice Management Consultations
        • SoloNet
        • Assist
      • Key Resources
        • Client Relationships
        • Communication & Research
        • Equity & Diversity
        • Ethics & Professionalism
        • Practice Management
        • Substantive Legal Knowledge
        • Trust Accounting & Safety
        • Wellness
        • Webinars
  • Regulation
    • Act, Code & Rules

      The Law Society of Alberta derives its authority from the Legal Profession Act and sets out standards through its Rules and Code of Conduct.
      • Act, Code & Rules
      • Hearings
        • Schedule
        • Decisions & Outcomes
        • Complaint Dismissal Appeals
        • Adjudicator Directory
        • Tribunal Office
      • Notices
        • Custodianship
        • Disbarment
        • Reinstatement
        • Resignation
        • Suspension
      • Unauthorized Practice of Law
  • Find a Lawyer
Resource Centre
  • Learning Centre
  • Lawyer Programs
    • Mentor Connect
      • Mentor Moments
    • Mentor Express
    • AdvisorLink
      • AdvisorLink Online Request
    • Locum Connect
      • Locum Listing
      • Locum Opportunity Listing
    • SoloNet
  • Key Resources
    • Client Relationship Management
    • Communication, Analytical & Research Skills
    • Ethics & Professionalism
    • Equity & Diversity
    • Practice Management
      • Leaving the Practice of Law
      • Returning to Practice
    • Substantive Legal Knowledge
    • Trust Accounting & Safety
    • Wellness
    • Webinars
      • Approved Legal Services Provider Webinar
      • Respectful Workplace Model Policy Webinar
  • Disaster Planning and Recovery
  • Student Resources
  • Public Resources
  • Upcoming Events
  • Media Room
  • eBulletins
  • Latest from the Law Society
  • Home
  • Resource Centre
  • Key Resources
  • Substantive Legal Knowledge
  • Signing Court Orders
Signing Court Orders

Lawyers owe a duty to the court to sign orders to which they have agreed or which have been granted by the court. In the absence of a valid objection to the form of the order, lawyers must sign them on behalf of the client even though the client later develops a change of heart. This may be so even after ceasing to act or being fired from the retainer.

Have you ever concluded an agreement for your client that is intended to be reflected in an order or judgment only to have the client change her mind? Typically, the other lawyer sends the form of order for consent and, although it looks appropriate, the client says, “Things have changed. He was late picking up the kids. Don’t sign the order!”

The dilemma arises from the inherent conflict between the duty of a lawyer to obtain instructions from the client and the duty not to carry out instructions that are contrary to professional ethics. A lawyer as agent for the client may have concluded an enforceable agreement on behalf of that client. If the lawyer followed the subsequent contrary instruction not to sign the order then, in enforcement proceedings the client might suffer costs or other penalties for failing to implement it. It is also a good way for a lawyer to make herself a witness.

Before the case of Martin v. Busenius, 1999 ABQB 100, ethical thought favoured a client centreed approach, binding a lawyer to act on the client’s instructions. In the absence of an undertaking by the lawyer, no ethical obligation should require the court order to be signed. Compare the conflict between the duties of giving a reasonable time extension to another lawyer and of implementing the client’s instructions to give no quarter.

But case law defined a duty to sign orders in agency law and trumped a mere ethical duty to take instructions. In Martin v. Busenius, the Alberta court enforced an agreement that was to be reduced to court order, where the client had later instructed counsel not to sign it. The lawyer had authority as agent to bind the client to the deal and the order mirrored it1. Veit, J. commented further:

After lawyers agree on the terms of an order, in the absence of exceptional circumstances there is a professional obligation to sign the order which reflects the agreement. (para.4)

In this case, Ms. Martin, through her lawyer, had agreed to the terms of the order that were faxed to her lawyer on December 11, 1998. She was obliged to sign the order reflecting that agreement. (para.25)

The failure to sign an order that had been agreed on is an egregious failure to properly conduct legal proceedings. (para.27)

The notion that lawyers owed a higher duty to the court than to respect client autonomy was reinforced several years later by the Ontario Court of Appeal in Folkes v. Greensleeves Publishing Ltd., [2002] 159 O.A.C. 99. In that case an order granted by the court was approved as to form by the lawyer for a party who later wanted to challenge it. Simmons, J.A. said:

Mr. Folkes indicates that counsel for the respondents acted improperly in endorsing the approval of Mr. Folkes’ counsel on the formal order of this court at a time when Mr. Folkes had indicated he intended to proceed on his own behalf. I reject this submission. In Chrysler Credit Canada Ltd. v. 734925 Ontario Ltd. (1991), 5 O.R. (3d) 65 Master Peppiatt noted that counsel have a professional obligation to the court and other counsel to approve an order to which there is no valid objection even after ceasing to act. I agree with his conclusion. To hold otherwise would create an inappropriate impediment to the proper processing of orders of the court. (para.47)

It appears that the duty to sign orders is linked to the role of lawyers as officers of the court.

Still, that feels somewhat unsatisfactory as an answer. Martin cited no precedent for the proposition and Folkes cited only Chrysler Credit, an equally unsupported case of an Ontario Master. Why then should the proper “conduct of legal proceedings” or the proper “processing of orders of the court” take precedence over the obligation of the lawyer to zealously represent the client? The client centreed approach makes it seem that client autonomy is diminished and that, in this context, a lawyer is made a servant of the state rather than of the client.

An answer is partly found in the Rules of Court. Northwest Territories Rule 407(3) and Alberta Rule of Court 9.6 both provide that orders and judgments of the court speak from the moment of pronouncement. Historically, this is probably the oldest rule in the book and explains the immediacy of “Off with his head!” in the time of court scribes. In Folkes, the appellant alleged that the court order was fraudulently back dated when in fact it only referred to the date of pronouncement. Chrysler Credit does rely on the Ontario equivalent Rule. A court order becomes the law from that day forward, whether signed or not.

The pronouncement rule rationalizes the duty to sign orders already granted. However, the duty expressed by the courts draws no distinction between orders granted and orders merely agreed to by counsel. Former Practice Advisor Barry Vogel mused doubtfully in 2000 that a principle of ethics should perhaps prevail over the law of agency in this context but surmised that judgments of the court carried more weight than opinions of the Practice Advisor.

In the result, lawyers appear to have a positive duty to sign court orders which have been granted or agreed, in the absence of a valid objection and notwithstanding the subsequent instructions of the client. In the face of persistent instructions by the client to implement instructions contrary to professional ethics, a lawyer must consider whether to withdraw from the representation. In Folkes moreover, the duty extended beyond the retainer and would be owed even after ceasing to act but, in this respect alone, there may a real distinction from Martin and orders merely agreed to by counsel.

____________________________________

1See also the discussion by the same judge in Neddow v. Weidemann, 2008 ABQB 378, issued after publication of this article

Printed from https://www.lawsociety.ab.ca on April 18, 2021 at 2:36:06 AM
Law Society of Alberta ©2021 Law Society of Alberta.
  • Latest
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Careers
©2021 Law Society of Alberta.
  • Who We Are
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Executive Leadership Team
    • Board & Committees
      • Back
      • Board Directory
      • Board Meetings
      • Committees
      • Other Bodies
    • Key Initiatives
      • Back
      • Indigenous Initiatives
      • COVID-19 Updates
    • Engagement with Public and Profession
    • Affiliations
    • Annual & Financial Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • Awards & Scholarships
      • Back
      • Distinguished Service Awards
      • Recognition of Service
      • Scholarships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • For the Public
    • Back
    • Find a Lawyer
    • Complaints
    • Finding Files & Wills
    • Public Resources
    • Financial Claims
    • Notices
    • Careers
  • Lawyers & Students
    • Back
    • Become a Lawyer
    • Membership Services
    • Forms & Certificates
    • Making A Payment
    • Trust Accounting & Safety
      • Back
      • Responsible Lawyers
      • Filing Requirements
      • Anti-Money Laundering Model Rules
    • Professional Development
    • Fraud & Loss Prevention
    • Practice Advisors
    • Practice Management Consultations
    • Approved Legal Services Providers
    • Complaints
    • Equity Ombudsperson
    • Alberta Lawyers Indemnity Association
      • Back
      • Report a Claim
      • Group Policy
      • ALIAlerts
      • ALIAdvisories
  • Resource Centre
    • Back
    • Learning Centre
    • Student Resources
    • Public Resources
    • Disaster Planning and Recovery
    • Upcoming Events
    • Media Room
    • eBulletins
    • Latest News
    • Lawyer Programs
      • Back
      • Mentor Connect
      • Mentor Express
      • AdvisorLink
      • Locum Connect
      • Practice Management Consultations
      • SoloNet
      • Assist
    • Key Resources
      • Back
      • Client Relationships
      • Communication & Research
      • Equity & Diversity
      • Ethics & Professionalism
      • Practice Management
      • Substantive Legal Knowledge
      • Trust Accounting & Safety
      • Wellness
      • Webinars
  • Regulation
    • Back
    • Act, Code & Rules
    • Hearings
      • Back
      • Schedule
      • Decisions & Outcomes
      • Complaint Dismissal Appeals
      • Adjudicator Directory
      • Tribunal Office
    • Notices
      • Back
      • Custodianship
      • Disbarment
      • Reinstatement
      • Resignation
      • Suspension
    • Unauthorized Practice of Law
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Lawyer Portal
  • Contact

Email: Education

Fill in the form below to get in touch with the Education department.
  • Drop files here or
      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

    Email: AdvisorLink

    Fill in the form below to get in touch with AdvisorLink
    • 1. AdvisorLink (operated by the Office of the Practice Advisors) and the Advisors accept no liability whatsoever arising from assistance given to lawyers or to any persons claiming through or under them.
      2. Lawyers are obligated to independently verify statements of law, procedure or fact made to them by the Advisor, before relying on them.
      3. AdvisorLink must not be used as a substitute for the lawyers’ own thorough research and analysis or for the lawyers’ own professional judgment.

    Email: Accounting

    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Accounting
    • Drop files here or
        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

      Email: Customer Service

      Fill in the form below to get in touch.
      • Drop files here or
          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

        Email: General Feedback

        Fill in the form below to get in touch with General Feedback
        • Drop files here or
            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

          Email: Communications and Media Relations

          Fill in the form below to get in touch with Communications and Media Relations.
          • Drop files here or
              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

            Email: Indigenous Initiatives Liaison

            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Andrea Menard
            • Drop files here or
                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

              Email: Membership Services

              Fill in the form below to get in touch with Membership Services
              • Drop files here or
                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                Email: Manager, Membership Services

                Fill in the form below to get in touch with Tina McKay
                • Drop files here or
                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                  Email: Elizabeth Aspinall

                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with Elizabeth Aspinall
                  • Drop files here or
                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                    Email: Jesse Mackenzie

                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Jesse Mackenzie
                    • Drop files here or
                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                      Email: Allan Guty

                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with Allan Guty
                      • Drop files here or
                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                        Email: SoloNet

                        Fill in the form below to get in touch with SoloNet
                        • Drop files here or
                            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                          Email: Practice Management

                          • Drop files here or
                              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                            Email: Nancy Bains

                            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Nancy Bains
                            • Drop files here or
                                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                              Email: Inform Trust Safety

                              Fill in the form below to get in touch with Inform Trust Safety
                              • Drop files here or
                                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                Email: Trust Safety

                                Fill in the form below to get in touch with Trust Safety
                                • Drop files here or
                                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                  Email: Information Management

                                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with Information Management
                                  • Drop files here or
                                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                    Email: Election

                                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Election
                                    • Drop files here or
                                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                      Email: Justicia Project

                                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with Justicia Project
                                      • Drop files here or
                                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                        Email: Locum Connect

                                        Fill in the form below to get in touch with Locum Connect
                                        • Drop files here or
                                            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                          Email: Mentor Connect

                                          Fill in the form below to get in touch with Mentor Connect
                                          • Drop files here or
                                              Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                            Email: Mentor Express

                                            Fill in the form below to get in touch with Mentor Express
                                            • Drop files here or
                                                Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                              Email: Indigenous Law Student Summer Employment Program

                                              Fill in the form below to get in touch with Indigenous Law Student Summer Employment Program
                                              • Drop files here or
                                                  Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                Email: ALIA

                                                Fill in the form below to get in touch with ALIA
                                                • Drop files here or
                                                    Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                  Email: ALIAlert fraud alerts

                                                  Fill in the form below to get in touch with ALIAlert fraud alerts
                                                  • Drop files here or
                                                      Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                    Email: Equity Ombudsperson

                                                    Fill in the form below to get in touch with Elizabeth Aspinall
                                                    • Drop files here or
                                                        Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                      Email: Tribunal Office

                                                      Fill in the form below to get in touch with Tribunal Office
                                                      • Drop files here or
                                                          Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.

                                                        Email: Custodianship

                                                        Fill in the form below to get in touch with Custodianship
                                                        • Drop files here or
                                                            Text, PDF, MSOffice, and Images only. Max size 20 MB.